Estate Tax Repeal: Miracle or Myth?

            For years, my clients and colleagues have repeatedly asked me, “When is Congress going to wipe out the estate tax?”  Routinely, I responded by saying, “The two things in life you can count on are death and taxes.”  That is, until June 7, 2001, when President Bush signed comprehensive tax law changes that eliminated the federal estate tax–a miracle many of us never expected to happen.

            In order to understand the benefit of the new changes, it is important to understand what the estate tax is and how it worked under the laws prior to June 7.

The estate tax:

            An individual’s estate is generally considered to consist of all of the property owned by that individual at his death (such as cash, stocks, retirement plans, life insurance, real estate, etc.). 

The estate tax is a tax imposed on an individual’s estate at the time of his death, and the tax is paid out of the estate before the deceased individual’s family or loved ones receive any of the property from the estate.  

Historically, many Americans have seen the tax as Congress unfairly taking  property that they worked their entire lives to accumulate.

            Under the laws prior to June 7, the estate tax was imposed on the entire fair market value of the estate on the date of the Individual’s death, and the maximum tax could reduce the entire estate by as much as 55 percent of the total estate.  The deceased individual’s family and loved ones could end up receiving less than half of the property that the individual accumulated during his lifetime. 

However, in an effort to provide some relief from the estate tax, Congress  provided every individual in the United States the right to leave $675,000 tax-free to family and loved ones.

            The problem with the estate tax has always arisen when an individual’s estate exceeded the $675,000 tax-free amount.

The changes:

            With the new changes, the estate tax remains in effect through 2009.  However, starting in 2002, the amount of an individual’s estate that passes tax-free increases to $1 million, and that tax-free amount gradually increases to $3.5 million by the year 2009.  At the same time, the maximum tax rate of the estate tax gradually decreases from the current 55 percent to 45 percent in 2009.

            Then, in 2010, the estate tax is completely repealed.  The estate of any individual dying on or after January 1, 2010 will not be subject to any estate tax, which means that the entire value of the estate will pass tax-free to the deceased individual’s family and loved ones. 

            This complete repeal of the estate tax is exactly the miracle for which many Americans have hoped for years.  Or is it?

The Myth:

            While many have celebrated the repeal of the estate tax, few have recognized one important provision of the new tax changes.  On January 1, 2011, the estate tax repeal is repealed.  Said another way, as of January 1, 2011, Congress reinstates the estate tax, and at that time, the estate tax laws revert back to the provisions in effect before the June 7 changes.  To many, it appears as though Congress is taunting Americans by repealing the estate tax and then reinstating it merely a year later.

            Many of my clients have asked me what this repeal, which seems mythical to them, means in terms of their estate planning, and I have told them, jokingly, that they should plan to die in the year 2010 because that is the only year in which  they would not have to pay any estate taxes. 

Since forecasting one’s death is not a viable option, I routinely advise clients that they should approach their estate planning with the expectation that their estate will be subject to some level of estate tax. 

In the meantime, we can all hope that Congress will extend the estate tax repeal so that death and taxes are no longer synonymous.

By Don D. Ford III

Ford & Mathiason LLP

Don D. Ford III is a partner in the law firm of Ford & Mathiason LLP. His practice focuses exclusively in the areas of Estate Planning, Probate, and Guardianship law.